I'm pretty happy with this, but it doesn't hold as long on the eyes for some reason, today is the first time i've tried it, so keep waiting for another sort of review on this Astor Kajal. I'm pretty happy with it, i mean it's only 8 dollars. It's really waterproof, but i have no problems getting rid of it with a normal make up remover for some reason.
It's the 081 Earth Shimmer one. I love it! It's a really nice brown and a bit of shimmer in it!